RUNNER-UPS1. Travis Haughton- story/sportsNegative feedback:- Some pictures had faces that were covered
- There were a couple of pictures that were kind of pointless; they didn't really go with the story
- "Tight" frames that didn't show enough of what was going on at the time.
Positive feedback:- The wierdness of the photos (cotton candy man)
- How well he showed levels in the photos
- Haloed bodies
My commentary:I liked the body language he cuaght, but a lot of the pictures confused me more than anything.
2. Jordan Murph- sportsNegative feedback:- The posed action not so good.
- The wave picture had no subject- no surfer.
- Had uninteresting pictures; they held nothing in them.
Positive feedback:- He caught unique moments in predited situations.
- The lighting is constantly good.
- He worked with shadows well.
My commentary:Most of the sports photos were real good and I liked how the photographer caught both action and emotion completely. I did not like both photo stories because I didn't really get it the whole time through.
3.Carlos Delgado- story/ sportsNegative feedback:- Some of the subjects' faces were hidden
- Contained cluttered backgrounds
- Color choice sucked (too much color or the black and white didn't help the pictures)
Positive feedback:- When he showed the lady's foot writing
- The irony of a sick mother with a son who smokes
- The baseball picture
My commentary:Personally, I liked the vibrant colors and cluttered backgrounds in the first photo story, it showed the lifestyle of the woman and her family. I didn't much like the sports photos or the seconds photo essay because I couldn't really tell what was going on.
4. Anthony Soufflé- photoj/ storyNegative feedback:- Familiar, ununique photos
- A lot of kid pictures- too safe
- Doesn't show extreme detail like the hook in the birds
Positive feedback:- The proffessional techniques in the football and surgical photos
- The photographer's sense of humor
My commentary:I really liked how each photo showed the story behind it. Like the woman crying or the surgeon. I alos liked the photo story because it showed the entire process in helping the birds.
WINNING PORTFOLIODustin SnipesWhat the judges saw as strengths:- He's in the action
- "griddy" feel (repitition technique)
- everybody is doing something in each picture- there's no idle subjects
- creativity
What I saw as strengths:- His uniqueness
- How it looks like he's right in the middle of everything
- The way he caught emotion
- And how well he used his surroundings (like the peoples' hands in the volleyball picture, or the batter's arm in the baseball picture)
What I saw as a weakness:I only thought the swimming picture was a bit confusing, but I still liked the concept.
RECAPThe process the judges went through:- Were the stories good or bad
- Did they have diversity or repitition in their portfolios
- Were there any completely ridiculous or weak pictures